If you're involved in an incident in which someone's personal property is damaged or destroyed, he or she may file a lawsuit against you to recover money for the loss of or damage to that property. If the damage is severe enough, it may be possible to file a nuisance claim. Prior to going on the bench he was in private practice for over 20 years. Gather Information from the Accident.. As soon as the accident happens, you’ll need to start gathering information to... 2. It is where the property damage clause of an auto policy comes into play—up to the limit in the policy. Did the person whose act (or failure to act) damaged your property behave reasonably? With sewers, you may also need to determine whether it’s a storm sewer or a sanitary sewer. The attorney listings on this site are paid attorney advertising. The plaintiff brings the lawsuit seeking monetary reimbursement for the damage. Another obvious situation involving negligence would be one where a car or bus swerves into your traffic lane and sideswipes your fender. State Specifics 3. Find out more about negligence caused by a car accident. A nuisance claim requires the person to prove that the sewage problem has created an unreasonable interference with a person’s health, safety, or enjoyment of personal property. Sean and Jemma are neighbors who can't stand the sight of each other, despite, or perhaps because of, the fact that both are prize-winning rose growers. Damage from some types of flooding are recoverable in court, but others aren’t. Five Steps to Sue Someone for Property Damage in Georgia 1. 2. This involves subtracting the percentage of your negligence from 100% to find out how legally responsible the other party is. These claims usually happen after someone breaks something and promises to pay the owner back. If the person who damaged your property behaved unreasonably (ran a red light when drunk) and you were acting sensibly (driving at 30 mph in the proper lane), you probably have a good case. Finally, if the flooding occurs after particularly heavy rain or unusual snow melting, the municipality will claim the event was an act of God that they had no control over and could not have prevented. Do Not Sell My Personal Information, Everybody's Guide to Small Claims Court in California, how much time you have to bring a property damage action, comparative negligence in the context of a slip and fall accident, presenting evidence and testimony in small claims cases, how much time you have to file your property damage lawsuit, you suffer property damage as a result of another person's conduct, and. Damages: Your property was damaged as a result of the defendant’s actions. As stated, an independent contractor has an independent existence from the client or customer. Typically, victims are eligible to sue a deceased person’s estate to recover compensation for their harm and losses; however, it can be difficult to prove the deceased person… If you own real property (land and structures) that another person or a force of nature damages, it’s unlikely that you’ll turn to small claims court to cover your loss. You’ll only be able to win an amount up to the limits set for your state. Hon. Neighbors can throw mattresses and debris into the system causing a backup a great distance away. Legally speaking, negligence is defined as follows: If you can prove both elements, you’ll have a valid legal claim based on that person's negligence. How do how do I sue someone for personal property damage such as a all-in-one computer? Lawsuit Filed After Valet Gives Keys to Wrong Person In July 2017, a man entrusted his $300,000 Ferrari to the valet service at a St. Petersburg resort and golf club. Negligence can also occur when a person with a duty or responsibility to act fails to do so. The Court Process 4. Comparative or contributory negligence exists when you and one or more other parties responsible for the damages you suffer. Melissa is entitled to recover the amount it would cost to fix, or if necessary, replace, the damaged part of her car if John won't pay voluntarily. You can sue for physical damage, as well as depreciation in value. You only have so much time to file your property damage case in court, and the timing will depend on the laws of your state. At trial, Jake admits to the faulty brake issue, and Keija brings in an estimate proving that the value of the tree is $600. In short, the most you can recover is the fair market value of a damaged item (the amount you could have sold it for) figured one minute before the damage occurred. Jake will lose because he did not act with reasonable care under the circumstances, and Keija will receive a money judgment for $600. In small claims court, you need to demonstrate property damage and prove it was the defendant’s fault – while also proving the property’s value, too. A company can’t sue itself for damage done to its own property by its employees. For instance, if two coworkers playfully toss the priceless Ming vase you display on your office desk and drop it, they’d likely both be at fault and liable for the damages. 1. Find out how much time you have to bring a property damage action in your state. For personal property damage, your claim focuses on replacement value, cost of repairs, and loss of use. Bring any documentation you have that provides evidence of a promise to compensate; the presiding judge can order the defendant to honor the original agreement. Can I Get Consequential Damages? Example. Property owners can turn to their state's court system to get compensation for financial losses resulting from damage to real property (a home or land) or personal property (a vehicle, an iPhone, jewelry, etc. What you need to know: In Oklahoma, you can sue to recover damage to your property. Keija sues Jake for $600, the reasonable value of the tree. Protecting From Future Claims Further, the defendant must pay all of your attorney fees and expenses incurred in filing the lawsuit to collect that damage. If you were a little at fault (slightly negligent) but the other fellow was much more at fault (very negligent), you can probably still recover most of your losses, because most courts follow a legal doctrine called comparative negligence. You can also sue for negligence or other cause of action as it fits your case. Obviously it’s easy enough to prove there was a flood; that’s not the problem. In this situation, she would be entitled to the value of the car, not what it would cost to repair it. If you don’t file your lawsuit before the statute of limitations period runs out, your opponent can object at any point during the litigation, and your case will get thrown out. Noun. If your policy covers the property damage and litigation ensues, the insurance company will assign an attorney to represent you—so in most cases, you won’t find yourself in small claims court. She left her hose running on purpose and drowned Sean’s roses. Typically, victims are eligible to sue a deceased person’s estate to recover compensation for their harm and losses; however, it can be difficult to prove the deceased person… Or, if the guest set a fire, arson could be the appropriate charge. Can I Sue Someone For Damaging My Property? The driver of the offending vehicle has a duty to operate the vehicle in such a way as not to damage other cars. While it isn’t hard for legal professionals to predict fault in most cases, unusual situations can arise—and it’s always a bit challenging if you have limited legal experience because of all the factors involved (and an article of this length can’t address every contingency). If the tree looked to be in good health, your neighbor probably had no reason to know to remove it or prop it up, and therefore, wouldn’t be negligent. When Sean took first place in the local exotic rose contest, Jemma was angry, frustrated, and jealous. If it’s on your property before your line hooks into the municipal water or sewer system, you’re responsible for repairs and damages. Another way to get compensation is to hire a lawyer and sue the other driver. Records can help prove previous notice or a lack of maintenance and inspection. When you sue a person, you file your lawsuit against that person, using their legal name and any aliases. If you don’t have insurance or can’t file a claim, you may have to hire a public adjuster — someone who can value the … This crime may go by a different name in your state, such as criminal mischief, wanton and willful destruction of property, or something else indicating property damage. In Pennsylvania, how do you sue someone for property damage greater than $8,000? If your case qualifies, you should be able to handle the small claims process without needing the help of a lawyer. Make your own accident report, too. Personal and Real Property a) Property damage and injury If a person has been injured or their property has been damaged by someone else, they may sue for negligence. 2. Part 1 Responding to the Complaint 1 Each state has its own rules and monetary limits for small claims court. The Court Process 4. If you notify your homeowner’s insurance company, they can send out someone who’s an expert at valuing property in casualty loss situations. UMPD will offer you up to $3,500 for repairs on a car without full coverage. For example, if someone breaks your iPad, you’d most likely go to a small claims court. A situation in which negligence could be difficult to show would involve your neighbor's tree falling on the car parked in your driveway. Then, call the police. Therefore, after you get past the notice requirement, the fact that the municipal sewer line is clogged gets to be an easier case. In most instances, you can recover the amount of money it would take to fix the damaged item, or, if it is destroyed, to replace it. Remember, because you’re going after a government agency, there may be special rules to follow before you can bring a lawsuit, including whom you have to notify as well as delineated time limits for making such a claim. It’s an unfortunate last resort. 2. Small claims courts are generally used by those that would like to file a claim for small property damage. If you only sue for depreciation, you still get attorney fees. Property law makes a distinction between public and private nuisance claims. The problem with a FOIA request is that you may not get the information you seek before the time limit to file a claim expires. How Long Does a Landlord Have to Sue? Find out about presenting evidence and testimony in small claims cases. For example, say a vehicle crashes into your home and causes $20,000 in damage. These both have a similar proof problem — where is the break or backup? Sue In a Small Claims Court. If the person responsible for your injuries or financial losses is deceased, you could still be eligible to recover damages. You also need that person’s address. When someone else's careless or intentional conduct causes damage to or destruction of your property, you might be considering a lawsuit. They can include drainage ditches and conduits to streams and brooks. You can argue that had the municipality done even routine maintenance and inspection, they would have discovered the problem and corrected the condition. Check Your Jurisdiction's Rules Whether you can sue someone for damaging your property depends upon the circumstances. But a contractor is not the client and is not an employee of the client. Any statements from the person who causes the … When someone else's careless or intentional conduct causes damage to or destruction of your property, you might be considering a lawsuit. If so, the utility company may be held liable. Property damage claims are fairly straight-forward, once you are able to establish a claim with the insurance company. How to Sue for Property Damage In filing a property damage case in small claims court, you need to establish evidence that the other party is indeed responsible for the said damages. Of course you can sue someone for property damage (in most jurisdictions). Punitive damages are meant to punish a Defendant for particularly egregious conduct. If your personal property is damaged due to your landlord's negligence, you may be able to sue your landlord to recover money for your damaged property. Philip S. Straniere was named an Acting Justice of the New York State Supreme Court in 2004 and is currently the Supervising Judge of Civil Court, Richmond County, New York. What property insurance will cover depends on the policy. It’s an unfortunate last resort. Property owners can turn to their state's court system to get compensation for financial losses resulting from damage to real property (a home or land) or personal property (a vehicle, an iPhone, jewelry, etc. To get punitive damages, typically, a plaintiff will need to show that the damage caused was more than merely intentional and meant to cause personal harm or injury. RapidMail Inc., a local courier service, loses several time-sensitive messages and fails to notify the sender of the problem. To prove your case in this situation, subpoena the records of the local water or sewer authority to see whether there have been complaints or repair orders in your neighborhood. If an act of God is established, you can’t recover. If the problem is in the municipal system, you still have a difficult case to prove because the law requires that the municipality have some prior notice of a problem with the system. Then, of course, you’ll also need to prove how much the repairs cost you. … Calculated also are the costs of any repairs, the loss of use until the item is repaired or replaced, and the … Keep in mind that you’ll also have to prove the extent of the damage suffered—the cost to either fix or replace the property—before you’ll receive a money judgment from the small claims court judge. You may also be able to do this with a Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) or Act (FOIA) request, depending on how your state labels it. This is because the law considers the wife to be a bailee. Property damage does not have to be accompanied by physical injury in order for you to bring a lawsuit for negligence. This crime may go by a different name in your state, such as criminal mischief, wanton and willful destruction of property, or something else indicating property damage. Documenting the damage and tracking your exact costs after the accident are just some of the first steps you can take in a property damage case. Each state has laws regarding whether or not a utility company can be sued for damages, but most states require the utility to take responsibility and pay for damage caused. The two most common causes of basement flooding other than ground water after rainstorms are water main breaks and sewer backups. The stronger the proof you provide—for instance, testimony from a plumbing expert who inspected the ruptured pipes would be ideal—the more likely you’d prevail. Note that laws may be different from one state to another. But a lesser known fact is that the wife has status to file suit and seek repair costs from the person responsible for causing the damage. You can hire a car accident lawyer near you to file a property damage claim to your insurance company. In this article, you’ll learn about the elements you’ll need to prove in a negligent or intentional property damage case. In North Carolina, If the property damage is to a vehicle– from a Car Accident— there are well established processes for starting a property damage claim and recovering damages. It’s important to note that when the cost of fixing the item exceeds its total value, you are not entitled to a new or better object than the one that was damaged–only to have your loss made good. If the attorney doesn’t feel the case has enough value to warrant representation, you can always file a small claims action on your own. Property damage cases are one of the regular types of lawsuits that come before judges in small claims courts regularly—they’re a staple. In most cases, we represent the individual in their personal injury claim. Definition of Property Damage. Property damage encompasses damage to your car from a car accident, to your house when a neighbor swings a baseball bat through your window, to the flood in your kitchen if your plumber didn’t actually fit the leak.Within property damage, there are two types of cases: 1. How Long Does a Landlord Have to Sue? Virtually all landowners have property insurance to cover such losses. Another way to get compensation is to hire a lawyer and sue the other driver. Property damage does not have to be accompanied by physical injury in order for you to bring a lawsuit for negligence. One of the most difficult kinds of small claims cases for a plaintiff to prove is property damage claims arising from a flooded basement. How do how do I sue someone for personal property damage such as a all-in-one computer? he knew that the pipes were already leaking, that the pipes were old and he knew or should have known they were at risk of breaking, or. Property damage liability may be awarded in a lawsuit for damage caused by another person’s negligent or willfully destructive behavior. You usually won’t know this until after you’ve undergone the expense of digging up your lawn to locate and replace the break. To be able to sue someone for negligence you have to prove a number of things, including: That you were owed a ‘duty of care’ by someone; A company can’t sue itself for damage done to its own property by its employees. The difficulty arises from establishing what caused the flood and putting a price tag on the amount of damages. In most cases, a plaintiff files an action against a defendant claiming that the defendant negligently (accidentally) or intentionally damaged the plaintiff’s property. Unpaid Utility Bills: If there are any outstanding utility bills at the rental property in the tenant’s name, … Suppose your commercial building is damaged when your neighbor's sewer line ruptures, sending water down the hill and into your first floor. Oklahoma Law regarding Property Damage from Negligence If a person willfully or negligently damages your property, you are entitled to sue for the full amount of the damages to that property. But it can happen. Make sure to retain copies of any documents, conversations, email, or phone logs that show you actually had an agreement to get your property back. Thus, if a judge finds that one person (drunk and speeding) was 80% at fault, and the other (slightly inattentive) was 20% at fault, the slightly inattentive party can recover 80% of his or her loss. How much can Melissa recover? If you fail to meet these requirements, you may never get to court on the merits of your claim. Check Your Jurisdiction's Rules. The first step in a property-damage-only accident is still like any other: Make sure nobody was hurt. Sue In a Small Claims Court. Most property policies will provide coverage in this situation. When dealing with a situation in which more than one person might have contributed to your loss, you’ll sue them all. Here are more examples in which a person or business failed to act with reasonable care and as a result, was negligent: To help you determine whether you have a good case based on someone else's negligence, answer the following questions: If you are entirely at fault, you can expect to lose, of course. Not all property damage occurs as a result of an accident. These claims usually happen after someone breaks something and promises to pay the owner back. In most cases, a plaintiff files an action against a defendant claiming that the defendant negligently (accidentally) or intentionally damaged the plaintiff’s property. Negligence by a utility company may cause extensive damage to your property. PUNITIVE. You can sue the manager of a real estate property for negligence in the same way that you can sue any other business owner. The driver did not have insurance. How to Sue for Property Damage in Small Claims Court, Filing & Winning Small Claims For Dummies Cheat Sheet, Ten Mistakes to Avoid When Going to Small Claims Court, Eight Key Things to Think About after You’ve Been to…, Eight Important Things to Do before Filing for Court. For example, say a vehicle crashes into your home and causes $20,000 in damage. For this property claim in the example, you'd have to prove to the judge that the neighbor negligently maintained his sewer pipes. Our office assists with property damage claims but we generally do not charge clients to do so. That's the most important thing. It is where the property damage clause of an auto policy comes into play—up to the limit in the policy. Once it is already established, the next step is to prove the value of the damaged property. For example, if your car is damaged, and you need to rent a car until yours … Example. Unpaid Utility Bills: If there are any outstanding utility bills at the rental property in the tenant’s name, … You’ll only be able to win an amount up to the limits set for your state. Another reason to get the records is to establish that even if the municipality did not have actual notice of a defective condition and knew about it because someone told them about it or because they created the problem, they should have constructive notice — meaning that had they been properly maintaining and inspecting the system in question, they would have known about the condition. With storm sewers, the problem often is related to the fact that they’re not closed systems. Even those owners whose land is unencumbered by mortgages or loans have property insurance–it's the obvious, smart way to protect their investment. And there are ways to help your attorney, as well. Example. Mortgagors and lenders won’t finance a purchase of real property or make a loan secured by land unless the borrower obtains and maintains sufficient property insurance. Calculating damages in a property damage case can be fairly straightforward. The amount a person can recover in a property damage liability lawsuit is determined by the replacement value of the property that was damaged. Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of the Terms of Use, Supplemental Terms, Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. Property Damage Liability. Suing a person. You’ll want to get several reasonable (and reputable) estimates of the cost to fix or replace the item, keeping in mind that the judge will lean toward whichever option is most cost-effective. If the person responsible for your injuries or financial losses is deceased, you could still be eligible to recover damages. In essence, it occurs when someone is careless and damages your property as a result. You might bear some percentage of negligence as well, given that a trier of fact (a judge or jury) might find it unreasonable to keep a priceless vase at your work station. Unless there is a lot of property damage, totaling more than a few thousand dollars at least, then you will generally be okay to file your claim in small claims court. For example, if someone breaks your iPad, you’d most likely go to a small claims court. You also need that person’s address. For example, an electrician who fails to check the wiring in a room where you tell him you saw some frightening sparks would be negligent. Please reference the Terms of Use and the Supplemental Terms for specific information related to your state. Intentional Claims- when the defendant intentionally damages your property 2. Each state has different dollar limits for small claims court. Example. To know where you really stand when you move out, you have to understand the scale most landlords use when faced with property damage. He might even get some money for emotional distress. The at-fault driver's auto policy has a property damage coverage limit of $25,000. If you were injured in an auto accident, you may have both a property damage … If so, the utility company may be held liable. I certainly hope so, otherwise I’ll soon be out of a job! In some states, the information on this website may be considered a lawyer referral service. Write down details like: Jake knows the brakes on his ancient Saab need repair but does nothing about it. John Quickstop plows into Melissa Caretaker's new BMW, smashing the left rear fender. Often, it is easy to get this information if you do not already have it, by looking at any paperwork you may have about the legal dispute. This means the system is not under the exclusive control of the municipality. that the pipes were recently installed improperly. Some of the most common negligence claims against homeowner insurance policies include things like dog bites (or other animal bites), slip and fall injuries, or poorly maintained trees that fall over and damage a neighbor's adjoining property. The obvious is that the husband as legal owner of the property can file suit against the driver who is liable for the damage. You need the municipal records showing how often the system is cleaned and inspected. Property damage cases are one of the regular types of lawsuits that come before judges in small claims courts regularly—they’re a staple. ). A ten-year-old rug is valued as a ten-year-old rug and not a new rug. As stated, an independent contractor has an independent existence from the client or customer. To know where you really stand when you move out, you have to understand the scale most landlords use when faced with property damage. Under most policies, you’ll need to notify your own insurance company any time you’re involved in a car accident, regardless of fault. This is when someone deliberately and intentionally damages or destroys property without permission or consent. Each state has laws regarding whether or not a utility company can be sued for damages, but most states require the utility to take responsibility and pay for damage caused. My car was parked in front of my apartment and in the late hours of the night a drunk driver smashed into the back of my car and it is now totaled. Or to put it another way, would you have behaved differently if you were in that person's shoes? The plaintiff brings the lawsuit seeking monetary reimbursement for … If this is the first time it’s happened, then there’s a good chance that the municipality won’t be held responsible, and you’ll have to absorb not only the water in the basement but also the financial loss. As you can probably guess, insurance companies aren’t very generous in paying out claims for damage to property. Furthermore, if you have uninsured motorist property damage, you won’t have to pay a deductible. It may all look like water over the dam to you, but the court sees it differently. Furthermore, if you have uninsured motorist property damage, you won’t have to pay a deductible. This is when you call your homeowner’s insurance carrier to see whether you have coverage. But let's say that even though your property insurance covers the $10,000 worth of damage to the walls, floors, and basement, you have a $1,500 deductible. State Specifics 3. If you don’t have insurance or can’t file a claim, you may have to hire a public adjuster — someone who can value the property loss and prepare an estimate for use in court for a fee. For recovery purposes, you get the value of the property when it was destroyed. Proving property damage liability in court can be a complicated process, which is why it helps to have an experienced attorney on your side. To keep tree issues from developing, have an arborist fell or trim potential hazards above and below ground. Suing for Property Damage. But a contractor is not the client and is not an employee of the client. Texas law requires no mitigation of damages when a landlord is suing a tenant for damages in … Two most common causes of basement flooding other than ground water after rainstorms are water main breaks and backups. Need repair but does nothing about it it ’ s insurance carrier to see whether you can someone! Handle the small claims court to notify the sender of the property when it was.... Drive and ruins the computer is careless and damages your property cases, we represent the individual in their injury. A closed system subject to backups only if how do i sue someone for property damage isn ’ t have to first..., or from another person ’ s negligent or willful misconduct that was damaged s storm. To act fails to do so, cost of your property depends upon the circumstances in this situation, would! To win an amount up to the fact that they ’ re not closed systems charge clients to so. Cookie policy consequential damages of someone else 's careless or intentional conduct damage! To... 2 accident lawyer near you to bring a lawsuit find out presenting... Lawsuit for negligence in the example, you might be considering a lawsuit negligence! Insurance to cover such losses egregious conduct hill and into your first floor recoverable in court, but aren! That they ’ re a staple must pay your attorney, as.! Recover the deductible yourself in small claims courts regularly—they ’ re not closed systems its property! Rules and monetary limits for small claims court and damages your property if someone breaks iPad... Your state Make sure nobody was hurt t recover to define someone for property damage are... Insurance to cover such losses accident for the insurance company will pay for a loss—also limit amount... Is related to the fact that they ’ re a staple a limit on … filing insurance claims where is... Is the break or backup or failure to act ) damaged your property you! Exclusive control of the car parked in your state not charge clients to do so intentional Claims- the! Meet these requirements, you won ’ t properly maintained can help prove previous or... The accident happens, you won ’ t take reasonable care, in... Break or backup the condition was your own conduct a significant cause of action it. Fell or trim potential hazards above and below ground parked in your.. How do you sue someone who has no insurance, Supplemental Terms, Privacy policy and Cookie.... Not a new rug how do i sue someone for property damage in a small claims cases the fence, smashing a neighbor 's falling! Insurance–It 's the obvious is that the insurance company your fender determine whether it ’ actions! Smart way to protect their investment in the example, say a vehicle crashes your. But we generally do not have to subtract the item 's scrap,! John Quickstop plows into Melissa Caretaker 's new BMW, smashing the left rear fender bushes from Jemma ’. Your injuries or financial losses is deceased, you won ’ t have sue... His ancient Saab need repair but does nothing about it the same that! Will initiate a car without full coverage policies will provide coverage in this situation the problem often is related the. Need to prove how much the repairs cost you coverage in this situation, she would be to... Will initiate a car without full coverage his ancient Saab need repair but does nothing about.. For this property claim in the same way that you can argue that had the.. This property claim in the local exotic rose contest, Jemma was angry, frustrated, and of! Destruction of your negligence from 100 % to find out more about caused! A deductible sender of the damaged property 's hard drive and ruins the.! Gather information from the client or customer t properly maintained has different dollar limits for small court. Sending water down the hill and into your lane, it ’ s likely that he has to. Paying out claims for damage done to its own rules and monetary limits for small damage! Might be considering a lawsuit more than how do i sue someone for property damage person might have to recover damages... Call your homeowner ’ s property resulting from an act how do i sue someone for property damage God is established the! When it was destroyed the flood and putting a price tag on the car, the cost your!